From: Delhilawyer <delhilawyer100@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Dec 19, 2024 at 3:46 PM
Subject: Message to Listing Registrar Mr P K Uppal and Listing Deputy Registrar Mr Kiran Kalra regarding non-compliance with Order of J. Gedela of 13 Nov in WP Crl 437/2018
To: <mljoffice@gov.in>, <aman.chawla@gov.in>, <secylaw-dla@nic.in>, <omlata.rawat@nic.in>, <dipendra.kanwar32@nic.in>, <kamal.rawat73@nic.in>, <anjurathi.rana@gov.in>, <ashok.gupta67@nic.in>, <anand.sunita@nic.in>, <hl.meshram@gov.in>, <ranjana.chopra@nic.in>, <asfa-culture@gov.in>, <amishra@ibm.gov.in>, <anand.kr@gov.in>, <sherdagar@gov.in>, <k.paul@nic.in>, <ajay.arora69@gov.in>, <teresa.kujur@gov.in>, <mk.maroria@nic.in>, <branchsec.mum-dla@gov.in>, <madhabc.prusty@gov.in>, <dhruvakumar.1973@gov.in>, <geeta.rana@nic.in>, <attorney-general@gov.in>, <m.nagasubrahmanyam@gov.in>, TUSHAR MEHTA <tusharmehta.sg@gmail.com>, <manish.malhotra@nic.in>, Vikramjit Banerjee <vikramjit.b@gmail.com>, <mahendra.prasad13@nic.in>, <kmnasgsc@gmail.com>, <sandeep.73@gov.in>, <svrajusenioradvocate@gmail.com>, <surajparkash.bcas@gov.in>, <n.venkataraman@gov.in>, <akr.singh67@nic.in>, aishwarya bhati <aishwaryabhati@gmail.com>, <rakesh.gupta67@gov.in>, <chetansharmamailbox@yahoo.co.in>, <parveen.rawat@nic.in>, <rdrastogi.asg@gmail.com>, Shashi Prakash Singh <shashiprakashsingh52@gmail.com>, ASGI SHASHIPRAKASH <officeasgalld@gmail.com>, <contact@satyapaljain.com>, <sr.adv.asok@gmail.com>, <rajeshk.chakrabarti@gov.in>, <asgiarls67@gmail.com>, <kn.mukundan@gov.in>, <asgi.patna@yahoo.com>, <anilkumar.addl.sgi@gmail.com>, <devangvyas216@gmail.com>, <bnsarmaadvocate@gmail.com>, Arvind Kamath <kamathlaw@gmail.com>, <r.kasibhatla@nic.in>, <praveensrivastava@cbi.gov.in>, <sharma.sk35@gov.in>, <babu.japan74@gov.in>, <mohd.muqeem@gov.in>, <neeraj.kmr20@gov.in>, <shrinet.dla@nic.in>, <uoidhc@gmail.com>, REGISTRAR GENERAL Delhi High Court <rg.dhc@nic.in>, <cp.sanjayarora@delhipolice.gov.in>, <verma.rs@nic.in>, <jaswinder.sing@nic.in>, Surya Prakash <khatri.suryaa@gmail.com>, Vishnu Sharma <advocatevishnu@yahoo.in>, Sanjeev Nasiar <Sanjeevnasiar@gmail.com>, <vedbaldev@rediffmail.com>, Rajesh Mishra <attorney.rmishra@gmail.com>, <dksharma1960@yahoo.co.in>, HIMAL AKHTAR <himalakhtarg@gmail.com>, <ajayindersangwan@gmail.com>, <ajay@sondhilawchambers.com>, <opfaizi@gmail.com>, <kcmiittal@yahoo.com>, Ramesh Gupta <advocaterg1949@gmail.com>, kkmanan <kkmanan@rediffmail.com>, Rajiv Khosla <advrajivkhosla@gmail.com>, <goswamiandassociates@yahoo.co.in>, <rakeshkochar@hotmail.com>, Rakesh Sherawat <rakeshsherawatadv@gmail.com>, Murari Tiwari <muraritiwari.adv@gmail.com>, <nkasana@uclmail.net>, Sanjay Rathi <advsanjayrathi@gmail.com>, <dksinghassociates2007@rediffmail.com>, Kumar Mukesh <kumarmukeshin48@gmail.com>, <attorneynitin@yahoo.com>, <manoj@singhassociates.in>, <guptapiyush@live.com>, <hshso@nic.in>, <mos.home@mha.gov.in>, <secy-ol@nic.in>, <secybm@nic.in>, <sois-mha@nic.in>, <dgawards@mha.gov.in>, <asfah@nic.in>, <aslwe@mha.gov.in>, <asctcr-mha@gov.in>, <adsecyne@mha.gov.in>, <as.police2-mha@gov.in>, <as.police1@mha.gov.in>, <asdm-mha@gov.in>, <aspm-mha@gov.in>, <prcca@mha.gov.in>, <jsuts-mha@mha.gov.in>, <asws-f@mha.gov.in>, <jsis@mha.gov.in>, <jscs@mha.gov.in>, <jscpg-mha@nic.in>, <js-is2@mha.gov.in>, <jsic-mha@nic.in>, <jsol@nic.in>, <arvind.kumar69@nic.in>, <jsffr@nic.in>, <jsf2-mha@mha.gov.in>, <jspm@nic.in>, <parthasarthi.g@nic.in>, <jsk@nic.in>, <jsf@mha.gov.in>, <jsbm2@mha.gov.in>, <jsbm@nic.in>, <jsctcr-mha@gov.in>, <jscis-mha@gov.in>, <jslwe-mha@nic.in>, <jsadmin-mha@nic.in>, <advisorlwe@mha.gov.in>, <cso@mha.gov.in>, <praveenk.yadav@nic.in>, <dlacbidhc@gmail.com>, <sumanchawala575@gmail.com>, Radhika Bishwajit Dubey <radhika.arora21@gmail.com>, <radhika.bishwajitdubey@bishwajitdubey.com>, <rv.dhc@nic.in>, <restt.dhc@gov.in>, <rga1.dhc@nic.in>, <rga-2.dhc@gov.in>, <rba.dhc@gov.in>, <rappellate.dhc@gov.in>, <rlisting.dhc@gov.in>, <rpnp.dhc@gov.in>, <rit.dhc@gov.in>, <roriginal.dhc@gov.in>, <rcaretaking.dhc@gov.in>, <cpo.dhc@nic.in>, <ppshcj-dhc@gov.in>, <jr.protocol2-dhc@gov.in>, <jrga.dhc@nic.in>, <jr-rules.dhc@gov.in>, <jrvigilance.dhc@nic.in>, <jrit.dhc@gov.in>, <jr-gazette1.dhc@gov.in>, <jr-estt1@dhc.nic.in>, <jr-estt2@dhc.nic.in>, <jr-ga2.dhc@gov.in>, <pilcell.dhc@gov.in>, <pio1.dhc@nic.in>, <apio.dhc@nic.in>, <drdigitization.dhc@nic.in>, <drlibrary.dhc@nic.in>, <drwrit.dhc@nic.in>, <drcriminal.dhc@nic.in>, <drappellate.dhc@nic.in>, <droriginal2.dhc@gov.in>, <drmedical.dhc@gov.in>, <drexam.dhc@nic.in>, <annualreport.dhc@gov.in>, <drscms.dhc@gov.in>, <drprotocol.dhc@gov.in>, <dr-ga2.dhc@gov.in>, <dr-eodb.dhc@gov.in>, <dr-ga1.dhc@gov.in>, <ddo.dhc@gov.in>, <arappellate.dhc@nic.in>, <argazette.dhc@nic.in>, <ar-gazette1B.dhc@gov.in>, <arcivil.dhc@nic.in>, <arpnp.dhc@nic.in>, <arcomputer.dhc@nic.in>, <arwrit.dhc@nic.in>, <arrkd.dhc@nic.in>, <aroriginal1.dhc@nic.in>, <aroriginal2.dhc@nic.in>, <arslp.dhc@nic.in>, <arcriminal.dhc@nic.in>, <arrgsecretariat.dhc@nic.in>, <arrules.dhc@nic.in>, <arhospitality.dhc@gov.in>, <arexam.dhc@gov.in>, <arexam-judicial.dhc@gov.in>, <ar-ga1.dhc@gov.in>, <ar-cjcms.dhc@nic.in>, <ajowrit1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojwrit2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojwrit3.dhc@nic.in>, <aojinspection.dhc@nic.in>, <aojdispatch.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcivil1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcivil2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcivil3.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcivil4.dhc@nic.in>, <aojpsa.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcriminal1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcriminal2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcriminal3.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcriminal4.dhc@gov.in>, <aojrkd1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojrkd2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojoriginal1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojoriginal2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojoriginal3.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcopyoriginal.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcompany1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcompany2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcopyappellate.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcopyinspect.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcomp.sty.dhc@nic.in>, <aojestablishment1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojestablishment2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcjsecretariat.dhc@nic.in>, <aojgazette1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojgazette2.dhc@nic.in>, <aoj-gazette2a.dhc@gov.in>, <aojfiling1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojfiling2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojgeneral1.dhc@nic.in>, <aojgeneral2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojpnp.dhc@nic.in>, <aojprotocol.dhc@nic.in>, <aoj-protocol2.dhc@gov.in>, <aojaccounts.dhc@nic.in>, <aoj-accounts2@dhc.nic.in>, <aojcash.dhc@nic.in>, <aojcash2.dhc@nic.in>, <aojvigilance.dhc@nic.in>, <aojvigilance2.dhc@gov.in>, <aojtranslation.dhc@nic.in>, <aojilr.dhc@nic.in>, <aojexam-judicial.dhc@gov.in>, <aojexam.dhc@nic.in>, <aojmedical.dhc@gov.in>, <aoj-rjc.dhc@nic.in>, <aojrkdkkd-dhc@gov.in>, <aojslp-civil5.dhc@gov.in>, <aoj-bmcc.dhc@gov.in>, <aoj-rticell.dhc@gov.in>, <librarian.dhc@nic.in>, <efiling.dhc@gov.in>, <mediation.dhc@nic.in>, <causelist.dhc@nic.in>, <jjc.dhc@nic.in>, <attendance.dhc@nic.in>, <gatepass.dhc@nic.in>, <recruitment.dhc@nic.in>, <netadmn.dhc@gov.in>, <vc-section.dhc@gov.in>, <cpc-del@aij.gov.in>, <ecourts-del@indiacourts.nic.in>, <coordinator.dac.dhc@nic.in>, <diac-dhc@gov.in>, <chair.dhc@gov.in>, <e-sewakendra.dhc@gov.in>, Seema Sapra <seemasapra@gmail.com>, <osd-gazette2.dhc@gov.in>, <r-writ.dhc@gov.in>, <rprotocol.dhc@gov.in>, <rexam.dhc@gov.in>, <rrkd.dhc@gov.in>, <courtmasterdbone@gmail.com>, <courtmaster253@gmail.com>, <courtmaster09@gmail.com>, <cmsanjay.dhc@gov.in>, <cmbharatgulati.dhc@gov.in>, <manish.prasad@dhc.nic.in>, <cmmridulasharma.dhc@gov.in>, <sachin.sharma@dhc.nic.in>, <cmrajeevkumar.dhc@gov.in>, <anand.pinani@dhc.nic.in>, <courtmaster@pmsingh.in>, <mahendra.kadian@dhc.nic.in>, <rajesh.malhotra@dhc.nic.in>, <pankaj.shukla@dhc.nic.in>, <cmnijeshnair@gmail.com>, <cmvijaypal.dhc@gov.in>, <cmnandansingh.dhc@gov.in>, <cmpankajgoel.dhc@gov.in>, <pramod@dhc.nic.in>, <daya.nidhi@dhc.nic.in>, <cmpankaj.dhc@gov.in>, <pramod.kumar@dhc.nic.in>, <sang.sudan2004@gmail.com>, <usha.rawat@dhc.nic.in>, <harikishan.berwa@dhc.nic.in>, <bhupesh.kumar@dhc.nic.in>, <dhcanilkumar@gmail.com>, <cmpooja.dhc@gov.in>, <cmatishgoel@gmail.com>, <mjcourtmaster@gmail.com>, <faisal.zaki@dhc.nic.in>, <devender@dhc.nic.in>, <n.shubhankar@dhc.nic.in>, <vcpeshi50@gmail.com>, <office.shashankgarg@gmail.com>, <anushkaaarora@abalawoffice.in>, Pratima N. Lakra <advocatepratima@gmail.com>, Pratima Lakra <pratilakra@gmail.com>, Anubha Bhardwaj <anubhabhardwaj77@gmail.com>, <officeadvmonika@gmail.com>, <office.sanjivkhanna@sci.nic.in>, Delhilawyer <delhilawyer100@gmail.com>, <seema.sapra@gmail.com>
To Listing Registrar Mr P K Uppal and Listing Deputy Registrar Mr Kiran Kalra,
On 13 December, I had mentioned first before Acting Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice Tushar Rao Gedela that in the interest of justice and keeping in mind that both WP Crl 437/2018 and WP Crl 2469/2023 were Petitions seeking enforcement of my fundamental right to life (Division Bench matters as per roster) and keeping in mind that Special Benches were being constituted and time availability was a factor, these two cases should also be transferred to the Division Bench hearing the other cases to facilitate hearing. I also pointed out that though each case was a separate cause of action with different facts, the facts in all cases were connected especially when it came to the issue of seeking protection.
Both Justice Bakhru and Justice Gedela had in principle agreed and Justice Bakhru told me to request Justice Gedela for this when the matter was taken up.
Justice Gedela therefore passed the following order in WP Crl 437/2018 and WP Crl 2469/2023 on 13 December.
"Ms. Sapra invites attention of this Court to the prayer made in the present petitions and states that keeping in view the nature of the case, it would be appropriate to place these matters before a Division Bench for consideration.
2. In view of the aforesaid, list before appropriate Bench on 20.12.2024, subject to the orders of Hon'ble the Acting Chief Justice."
On 13 December, Justice Gedela recused and first said since he was recusing he could not pass this order. Yet when the order was published, it said this. The recusal order of Justice Gedela was in the Division Bench matters.
Please see WP Civil 9860/2024 where a similar order of Justice Mini Pushkarna resulted in a transfer of that case from the Single Bench to the Division Bench. That order dated 7 November reads as follows.
"1. The petitioner in person submits that the present petition needs to be placed before the Division Bench.
2. Accordingly, list before the appropriate bench, of which HMJ Mini Pushkarna, is not a member, subject to the order of Hon'ble Chief Justice, on 05th December, 2024."
In fact Justice Gedela had stated that he would pass the same order as in WP Civil 9860/2024.
On 16 December I brought this to the attention of Mr Uppal and Mr Kiran Kalra so that WP Crl 437/2028 and WP Crl 2469/2023 could also be transfered to the Division Bench.
I checked the advance cause list today and WP Crl 437/2018 and WP Crl 2469/2023 are still listed before a Single Bench.
Please ensure that this order of Justice Gedela is placed before the Acting Chief Justice so that WP Crl 437/2018 and WP Crl 2469/2023 are also transferred to the Division Bench as WP C 9860/2024 was done.
There appears to be some deliberate flouting of Court orders happening here. Please direct a vigilance enquiry.
Seema Sapra
Advocate
No comments:
Post a Comment