Complaint against Judge A K Sikri, Judge Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice Gita Mittal, and Judge Rajiv Shakdher to the Chief Justice of India, the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court, the Secretary General of the Supreme Court of India, and the Registrar General of the Delhi High Court - Writ Petition (Civil) 1280/ 2012 - in the matter of Seema Sapra v. General Electric Company and Others in the Delhi High Court

Globally, INSOL member organizations have separate judicial wings meant only for judges, but in India we have four judges who are part of the lawyers' organization. This is undesirable as it provides both the potential and opportunity to "influence" these judges. These four judges have crossed over the ethical boundary and moved into unethical territory that is not appropriate for judges and creates potential conflict of interest situations.

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Seema Sapra <seema.sapra@googlemail.com>
Date: Sat, Apr 19, 2014 at 2:32 PM
Subject: Complaint against Judge A K Sikri, Judge Sanjay Kishan Kaul,
Justice Gita Mittal, and Judge Rajiv Shakdher to the Chief Justice of
India, the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court, the Secretary
General of the Supreme Court of India, and the Registrar General of
the Delhi High Court - Writ Petition (Civil) 1280/ 2012 - in the
matter of Seema Sapra v. General Electric Company and Others in the
Delhi High Court
To: Sapra <seemasapra@hotmail.com>, Seema Sapra <seema.sapra@googlemail.com>
Cc: Bhim Sain Bassi <cp.bsbassi@nic.in>, "rg.dhc@nic.in"
<rg.dhc@nic.in>, "sho-tilakmarg-dl@nic.in" <sho-tilakmarg-dl@nic.in>,
"dcp-newdelhi-dl@nic.in" <dcp-newdelhi-dl@nic.in>,
"dcp-central-dl@nic.in" <dcp-central-dl@nic.in>, "supremecourt@nic.in"
<supremecourt@nic.in>, Rajiv Khosla <advrajivkhosla@gmail.com>, Jatan
Singh <jatan_singh@yahoo.com>, Abhijat Bal <abhijat.bal@gmail.com>,
Ashutosh lohia <lasutosh@gmail.com>, Vikram Singh Panwar
<vikrampanwar2010@gmail.com>, Anoop Bagai <anoopbagai@gmail.com>,
ashok.bhasin@yahoo.co.in, Aruna Tiku <arunatikuadvocate@yahoo.com>,
Sunil Mittal <sunilmittaladvocate@gmail.com>, Meghna Mittal Sankhla
<meghna@sankhla.in>, kadambari@ucolindia.com, Amit Sharma with khosla
<advocateas@gmail.com>, Laxmi Chauhan <laxmichauhanmalhan@gmail.com>,
Pankaj Kapoor <lawyerpankaj@gmail.com>, director@aiims.ac.in,
cp.ggn@hry.nic.in, jtcp.ggn@hry.nic.in, dcphq.ggn@hry.nic.in,
secy-mines@nic.in, cvo@airindia.in, sundari@airindia.in,
Ashutosh.Dumbare@airindia.in


Complaint against Judge A K Sikri, Judge Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice
Gita Mittal and Judge Rajiv Shakdher to the Chief Justice of India,
the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court, the Secretary General of
the Supreme Court of India, and the Registrar General of the Delhi
High Court - Writ Petition (Civil) 1280/ 2012 - in the matter of Seema
Sapra v. General Electric Company and Others in the Delhi High Court


There is an organization called INSOL India which is a registered
society under the Societies Registration Act. It describes its aims
and objectives as follows:

AIMS & OBJECTIVES OF INSOL INDIA

The objects of the Association, which is a non-Political, non-Trading
and Non-Governmental Association, are :

To bring together the members of the legal fraternity in various
disciplines of law in India and outside India for closer co-operation,
development, understanding and promotion of law, more particularly,
law relating to insolvency and related laws;
To promote studies, diffusion and advancement of international and
comparative law.
To act as a forum for the promotion of national participation, debate
and awareness in the filed of law and policy.
To conduct research, hold seminars and discussions, develop and
maintain a library, collect documents relating to the growth and
development of laws in India and to undertake comparative studies of
legal developments in other countries of the world.
To hold workshops, seminars, conferences, discussion and meetings on
the subjects relating to jurisprudence and legal practice.
To develop contacts and cooperate with various other institutions in
different parts of the world.
To develop, promote and assist professional bodies and groups involved
in the practice of law, administration of Justice and legal education.
To undertake any work and to engage in any activity as may be
necessary for the purpose of implementation of the objects hereinabove
and any other objects that INSOL India may adopt.
To use and develop law as a source and an instrument towards social
change for development as well as building co-operation among the
people.

It has a website at http://www.insolindia.com.

This website contains the following information on the executive
committee of INSOL India:

EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE OF INSOL INDIA

Patron
Members
Chief Patron
Mr. Justice D. P. Wadhwa - Profile
Retired Judge, Supreme Court of India
Chairman, TDSATJt. Secretary
Mr. Sanjay Bhatt
Founder President
Mr. Justice Manmohan Sarin - Profile
Former Chief Judge, J & K High Court,
Lok Ayukt, NCT of DelhiTreasurer
Mr. Ajay Verma - Profile
Advocate
Supreme Court of India
Patron
Mr. Arun Jaitley - Profile
Member of Parliament & Senior Advocate,
Supreme Court of IndiaMember
Mr. Justice Rajiv Shakdher
President
Mr. Justice A. K. Sikri - Profile
Judge, Delhi High CourtMember
Mr. Parag P. Tripathi - Profile
Senior Advocate
Sr. Vice President
Mr. Justice Sanjay K Kaul - Profile
Judge, Delhi High CourtMember
Mr. P. H. Parekh - Profile
Senior Advocate
Sr. Vice President
Mr. A. S. Chandhiok - Profile
Senior AdvocateMember
Mr. Ashwani Puri
Vice President
Mr. Sushil Salwan - Profile
Advocate
Supreme Court of IndiaMember
Mr. Rakesh Munjal - Profile
Senior Advocate
Seceretary General
Mr. Rupinder Suri
AdvocateMember
Mr. Dalip Mehra - Profile
Advocate
Permanent Invitee
Mr. Sumant BatraMember
Mr. Rajiv Nayar
Senior Advocate
Secretary
Ms. Maneesha DhirMember
Mr. N K Jain


Its membership is listed as follows:

MEMBERS LIST OF INSOL INDIA

1. A.S. Chandhiok & Co.Law Firm
2. Arun JaitleySenior Advocate
3. Arvind K. NigamAdvocate
4. Ajay K. JainAdvocate
5. Asha BatraAdvocate
6. B.C. ThirurengadamAdvocate
7. C.V. FrancisAdvocate
8. Dalip MehraAdvocate
9. Dhir & Dhir Associates (Alok Dhir)Law Firm
10. D.C. Singhania & Co.Law Firm
11. Grant Thorton(Vishesh C Chabdhiok)Accountany Firm
12. Justice Gita MittalAdvocate
13. H.P.SinghAdvocate
14. IFCI Ltd. (K.A.Nazmi)Financial Institution
15. Jusice Arjan K. SikriJudge
16. Jusice D.P.Wadhwa(Retd.)Former Judge
17. Justice Manmohan SarinJudge
18. Justice Sanjay K. KaulJudge
19. Jatinder Kumar SethiAdvocate
20. Kesar Dass B & Associates (Sanjay Bhatt)Law Firm
21. Luthra & Luthra (Rajiv Luthra)Law Firm
22. M.D.KantherAdvocate
23. Mohinder M KhannaChartered Accountant
24. Manmohan Lal SarinSenior Advocate
25. Mukul RohtagiSenior Advocate
26. Niraj Kishan KaulSenior Advocate
27. O.P.DuaSenior Advocate
28. Parag P TripathiSenior Advocate
29. P.N. MehtaChartered Accountant
30. Pradeep SanchetiAdvocate
31. Pricewaterhousecoopers (Ashwani Puri)Accountany Firm
32. P.H.Parekh & Co. (P.H.Parekh)Law Firm
33. R.K. JainSenior Advocate
34. Rajiv KapoorAdvocate
35. Rajan DhawanChartered Accountant
36. Rakesh MunjalSenior Advocate
37. Rajiv NayarSenior Advocate
38. Rupinder Singh Suri & Co.(R.S.Suri)Law Firm
39. Sonali GuptaAdvocate
40. Sanjeev NandaChartered Accountant
41. Sanjay BhattAdvocate
42. S.C. VasudevaChartered Accountant
43. Sumant BatraAdvocate
44. Satbir Singh SidhuAdvocate
45. Sushil Dutt SalwanAdvocate
46. Sanjeev SapraChartered Accountant
47. Sudhanshu BatraAdvocate
48. TFCI Ltd. (R.N.Jha)Financial Institution
49. U.K. ChaudharySenior Advocate
50. Virender GandaAdvocate
51. V. ShekharAdvocate

ASSOCIATE MEMBERS
1. Arun WailaAdvocate
2. Ajay VermaAdvocate
3. Anil Kumar SharmaLaw Officer, HUDCO
4. Anil MahajanCompany Secretary
5. Amit GuptaCompany Secretary
6. Anil ShrivastavAdvocate
7. Adesh Chand JainAdvocate
8. Alok GoelChartered Accountant
9. Amit DhingraAdvocate
10. Aprna ViswanathAdvocate
11. Ali IshtiaqAdvocate
12. B. K. JainChartered Accountant
13. M. M. GuptaLaw Officer, IFCI Ltd.
14. B. M. Damodara RaoLaw Officer, HUDCO
15. Binay Kumar MishraAdvocate
16. Chandra Shekhar GuptaChartered Accountant
17. D. Narasimha RaoAdvocate
18. Deepamala RanganathanAdvocate
19. Dharmendra Prasad MohantyAdvocate
20. E. R. KumarAdvocate
21. Gopal Jee JhaAdvocate
22. Girish VasishthaAdvocate
23. Harish GambhirChartered Accountant
24. Indoo VermaAdvocate
25. Jitendra Pal SinghAdvocate
26. Jayant NathAdvocate
27. Manish KumarAdvocate
28. M. L. RajoraLaw Officer, IREDA
29. M. M. GuptaLaw Officer, IFCI Ltd.
30. M. P. MehaniAdvocate
31. Neeraj ChaudhariAdvocate
32. Nilesh SharmaChartered Accountant
33. Naresh Kumar SinhaCompany Secretary
34. Prabhat ShroffAdvocate
35. Praveen AgarwalAdvocate
36. P. B. SrinivasAdvocate
37. Pradeep Kumar GaurChartered Accountant
38. Prasenjit KarLaw Officer, IFCI Ltd.
39. R. K. SoniLaw Officer, HUDCO
40. R. Jawahar LalAdvocate
41. Rohit Mammen AlexAdvocate
42. Robin Ratnakar DavidAdvocate
43. Ravchi KhuranaAdvocate
44. Rajnish Kumar SinghAdvocate
45. Vivek SibalAdvocate
46. V. U. EradiAdvocate
47. Saleem AhmedAdvocate
48. Sudha SharmaAdvocate
49. Sumant DeAdvocate
50. Sanjeev JhaCompany Secretary
51. Sunil Kumar JhaAdvocate
52. Sandeep ParekhAdvocate
53. Sameer ParekhAdvocate
54. Vijay Kumar ChopraAdvocate
55. Vikram BhatiaAdvocate
56. Y. N. BhardwajAdvocate
57. Zubeda BegumAdvocate
58. Zulfokir Kumar ShafiAdvocate



It is illegal, unconstitutional and unethical for Judge A K Sikri,
Judge Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice Gita Mittal and Judge Rajiv Shakdher
to be part of INSOL India and to be members of its executive
committee. Such membership facilitates judicial corruption by
providing avenues for undesirable contact between judges and lawyers
outside court. Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul's family members are
practicing lawyers in Delhi (his daughter and brother). Justice A K
Sikri's family members are also practicing lawyers in Delhi (his wife,
son, daughter in law and brother).

An out of town conference is apparently being organised over a weekend
by INSOL India next month which Judge A K Sikri and Montek Singh
Ahluwalia will both attend. On 17 February 2012, Judge A K Sikri
participated in an unsuccessful conspiracy to murder me to prevent me
from filing the captioned corruption petition which involves Montek
singh Ahluwalia and General Electric Company.

Such a junket will only promote judicial corruption,

Please take action on this complaint immediately.

Seema Sapra